Your Custom Dessert Studio
Handcrafted sugar cookies, cupcakes & event desserts, made with love in Matawan, New Jersey.
Ordering Made Easy & Sweet
Follow these simple steps to bring your delicious vision to life. It's a piece of cake (or cookie)!
Browse & Dream
Explore our offerings and pricing to find the perfect treats for your occasion.
Check Availability
Reach out to see if your desired date is open. We recommend 2+ weeks notice!
Place Your Order
Fill out the order form with all the delicious details of your custom request.
Secure Your Date
Pay your 50% deposit to get your sweet event officially on our calendar.
Pick Up & Enjoy!
Collect your beautiful, handcrafted desserts and be the star of the party.
Our Sweet Offerings
From custom cookies to delightful cupcakes, find the perfect treat for any celebration.
Assorted Flavor Cookies
A delicious mix of our classic and seasonal flavored cookies. Perfect for any gathering.
starting at $40/dozen
Decorated Sugar Cookies
Custom, hand-decorated vanilla bean sugar cookies designed to match your theme.
$6 each
Cupcakes
Fluffy, flavorful cupcakes with our signature buttercream, tailored to your event's colors.
starting at $36/dozen
Cookie Kits
Unleash your inner artist! Our kits include everything you need for a fun decorating session.
starting at $8
A Few Sweet Notes
To ensure we create the best for you, here are a few key details about our process.
Order Minimum: $36
This helps us dedicate the perfect amount of love and detail to every order.
Deposit: 50% to book
A non-refundable deposit secures your spot on our baking calendar.
Lead Time: 2 weeks
We recommend booking at least two weeks in advance to ensure availability.
Rush Fee: $25
Need something sooner? Orders with less than 2 weeks notice may incur a rush fee.
Deposit Window: 72 hours
Unpaid deposits will be cancelled after 72 hours to open the date for others.
Final Payment
The remaining balance is due the day before your scheduled pickup.
A Gallery of Sweet Moments
Let our work speak for itself. Here's a taste of what we can create for your special events.
Join The Fun!
From hands-on decorating classes to local pop-ups, there are more ways to enjoy Oh Sugar!
Cookie Decorating Classes
Learn the sweet art of cookie decorating! Perfect for a girls' night out, a creative date, or just for fun.
Join a Cookie ClassPop-Ups & Events
Find us at local businesses, markets, and farms around New Jersey. Follow on Instagram for the latest schedule!
View Upcoming Events
Baked from the heart
Hi, I'm the heart behind Oh Sugar! What started as a passion for baking and decorating in my home kitchen has blossomed into a beautiful small business fueled by creativity and community.
I believe that desserts should be more than just sweet—they should be meaningful. Every cookie and cupcake is a tiny work of art, made to bring a little extra joy to your most cherished moments. Thank you for supporting this local dream and letting me be a part of your celebrations.
Ready to Create Something Sweet?
With clear pricing, simple ordering, and thoughtful, custom desserts, your perfect treat is just a click away. Let's start planning!